Computer screen displaying stock metrics and graphs as an abstract representation of short squeeze phenomenon.

Why Are Short Squeezes So Rare?

Short squeezes are one of the most dramatic and high-stakes events in the stock market, capable of producing meteoric price rises that defy expectations. But why are they so rare, and what should investors know before navigating these turbulent waters? In this guide, we’ll break down the phenomenon of short squeezes, their causes, and how to approach them with the thoughtful, informed decision-making central to Prospero.ai’s mission.

What Is a Short Squeeze?

A short squeeze occurs when short sellers find themselves in a bind. A short seller is an investor who borrows shares to sell at a high price, with the aim to buy them back later at a lower price. Their bind occurs when a stock's price unexpectedly skyrockets. This forces short sellers to close their positions by buying back shares which adds fuel to the upward price momentum. This creates a feedback loop of rising prices driven by urgent buying.

While the concept is simple, the execution of a short squeeze requires a rare alignment of conditions:

  1. High Short Interest: A substantial portion of the stock’s float is sold short, creating pent-up buying demand.
  2. Bullish Catalyst: Positive news, earnings surprises, or even market speculation can trigger a squeeze.
  3. Limited Supply: Stocks with low trading volume or restricted availability amplify the price surge.
  4. Investor Momentum: Retail and institutional traders piling in can accelerate the upward trend.

Why Are Short Squeezes So Rare?

The scarcity of short squeezes stems from how unlikely it is for these conditions to align perfectly. Most stocks have relatively low short interest, making them less susceptible to dramatic squeezes. Additionally, regulatory frameworks, margin requirements, and improved market data have reduced the frequency of extreme short selling.

However, when short squeezes do occur, the results can be extraordinary. Take GameStop (GME) in 2021, where retail traders united to spark one of the most iconic short squeezes in history, or Tesla (TSLA) in 2020, where fundamental shifts in profitability and growth fueled a squeeze that later proved sustainable.

Spotting the Signs of a Short Squeeze

Identifying a potential short squeeze before it unfolds is challenging but not impossible. Key metrics and market behaviors to watch include:

  • Short Interest Ratio (Days to Cover): Indicates how long it would take short sellers to buy back shares at the current trading volume. Higher ratios suggest heightened risk of a squeeze.
  • Short Interest as a Percentage of Float: A figure exceeding 10% can signal significant bearish bets, increasing the squeeze potential.
  • Unexplained Price Surges: Sudden, dramatic price increases without news can point to a squeeze in motion.

How to Approach Short Squeezes

Short squeezes might seem like a golden ticket, but they’re fraught with risk. Here’s how to approach them strategically:

  1. Focus on Fundamentals: Look beyond the hype. Does the stock have a growth story that justifies its price movement, or is it purely speculative?
  2. Limit Your Risk: Set clear loss limits before trading and avoid overexposing your portfolio to a single stock.
  3. Avoid Emotional Decisions: Fear of missing out (FOMO) often clouds judgment during volatile market conditions. Stay disciplined.
  4. Know When to Step Back: If a short squeeze doesn’t align with your long-term goals, there’s no shame in sitting it out.

Our CEO George Kailas shares his analogy comparing short squeezes to a game of musical chairs.

Lessons from History

Not all short squeezes are created equal. Tesla’s 2020 rally was underpinned by improving fundamentals, eventually leading to its inclusion in the S&P 500. By contrast, GameStop’s dramatic rise was driven by market psychology rather than intrinsic value. Both cases underscore the importance of understanding the forces at play.

A Data-Driven Approach with Prospero.ai

Navigating complex phenomena like short squeezes requires a combination of market knowledge and actionable insights. Prospero.ai equips investors with powerful tools like AI-driven stock screeners and risk management platforms to make informed, confident decisions. Whether you’re spotting opportunities or managing risks, our platform provides the clarity and control you need to succeed.

Invest smarter. Trade with confidence. Prospero.ai will guide you through each twist and turn of the market.

Prospero.ai Newsletters

Unique Insights

Investing Newsletter

Invest long-term. Bi-Weekly insights. Consistently beating the S&P 500 by 50%.

Read on Substack ›
  • Bi-Weekly update
  • Predominantly long-term
  • Minimum 1 week hold times
  • Optional/simplified downside protection strategies

Trading Newsletter

Stay ahead. Daily updates with 27% better returns than S&P 500 since inception.

Read on Substack ›
  • Updates almost every trading day
  • Opportunistic strategies
  • Ranges in complexity from sector and macro focused plays to event based pair-options trades.